Safe Nations | Community meeting kit A 30-minute discussion about Mutual AI Resilience ──────────── Library or newsletter notice What if a storm cuts power to the pumps? In September 2017, Florida Power & Light asked Ontario’s Hydro One for help during Hurricane Irma. Hydro One reported that it mobilized 175 employees within 24 hours. The utilities already had a way to ask for help across the border. Mutual AI Resilience (MAR) proposes that countries keep a channel like this open for essential services. Try a local drill. A water pumping station loses power. Two lists disagree about whether a visiting crew is free. The sending utility decides what it can offer. The local dispatcher checks the offer and can decline it. Would the pumps run sooner if AI flagged that disagreement? Give two teams the same lists and phone contacts. Let one team use an AI flag. Record when the crew assignment is confirmed and when the pumps restart in the drill. Keep the phone process if the flag only adds calls. Jesse Shelley · CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 · https://safenations.org/ ──────────── Read aloud When Hurricane Irma threatened Florida, a utility in Ontario answered a request for crews. Mutual AI Resilience, or MAR, asks how countries could arrange help like that, check an offer and still decide for themselves when to act. Imagine a water pumping station here loses power. Two lists disagree about which crew is free. An AI tool could flag the mismatch. Who could check it, and what could the water operator do while waiting? ──────────── Before you meet Choose a service people know. A water system, a bus route or a meal delivery service gives people something specific to discuss. Pick one and find its public information page. Invite different kinds of experience. Ask a resident who uses the service, a person who helps run it and someone who can check the public record. If a voice is missing, write down the question you would ask them. Make room for more than spoken answers. Send the agenda and a plain-text copy in advance. Offer paper notes and a way to send a question afterwards. Ask before naming or quoting anyone in the recap. ──────────── Invitation to adapt Subject line — A 30-minute discussion about [local service] Join us on [date and time] at [accessible location or call-in details]. We’ll walk through [one toolkit example] and ask what two partners can do for people who depend on [service]. We’ll choose one thing to check and discuss whether AI would help with that step. You’re welcome to bring a question, share an experience or just listen. No technical background is needed. For a paper copy, another way to take part or access information, contact [organizer]. ──────────── 30-minute agenda MAR’s long-term aim is to reduce the risk of war by giving countries a practical reason to cooperate during a crisis. A local drill can show whether two teams can verify an offer and keep a service available. Assessing any effect on conflict between countries takes separate evidence. 0–5 min | Choose a decision Read the documented event and the exercise from one example. Ask a resident what they need to know or be able to do by the end. 5–12 min | Take the partners’ roles Have one person offer an update or help. Ask the other to check it, then accept, change or decline the offer. What information can each keep private? 12–22 min | Try a conflicting update Change one fact in the exercise. Trace how the responsible person would check it by phone or on paper. Take away the shared channel for one round. Record what each partner can still do. If the group proposes AI, name the step it would change and who checks its answer. 22–30 min | Agree on one follow-up Read back the decision and one objection. Pick a result that would change the decision, such as a slower confirmation or a resident sent to the wrong place. Name who will check it and when they will report back. ──────────── How to check a claim Find the original account. Hydro One described reciprocal assistance agreements among North American utilities. It reported receiving Florida Power & Light’s request on September 9, 2017, and mobilizing 175 employees within 24 hours. Say what the example supports. The record shows that a request led to crews mobilizing across a national border. Measuring how long residents waited for power would require service records. The added value of AI remains a question for a separate test. Turn an open claim into a question. Compare the usual mutual-aid process, a shared crew list checked by phone, and that same list with AI flagging conflicts. Give teams the same reports and crews. Record time to a confirmed assignment, time to resumed pumping and staff time spent checking errors. If the flag adds work and service resumes just as quickly with the simpler process, keep the list and the phone call. Hydro One, “Hydro One awarded for outstanding restoration efforts after Hurricane Irma,” January 10, 2018. ──────────── Ten worked examples MAR asks whether countries can protect essential civilian services by checking warnings and arranging help while each keeps control of its own decisions. Its longer-term aim is to sustain cooperation and reduce the risk of war. The crew and postal cases draw on documented international cooperation. The local cases let a group practice one part of that idea. A faster repair or a clearer notice can tell us about that service. Whether such cooperation reduces conflict needs separate evidence. Choose a service the group knows. Assign the roles and pause at the two questions before reading the sample decision. If you test AI, use the same reports and resources for the usual process, the agreed procedure, and that procedure with AI. Ask which choice helped people get the service and what it cost. ──────────── When is a repair crew actually available? MAR goal Preserve sovereign control. Two utilities can lend crews across a border while each controls its own people. Checking an offer before assigning work could get power back to a priority service sooner. Documented event On September 9, 2017, Florida Power & Light asked Ontario’s Hydro One for help with Hurricane Irma. Hydro One reported that it mobilized 175 employees within 24 hours. Their trip and work in Florida took 14 days altogether. Meeting exercise A storm cuts power to a pumping station. A visiting utility has offered a crew. Its truck is delayed, although the shared list still says “available.” Decide which crew, if any, to assign. Who does what The sending dispatcher confirms who can travel. The receiving dispatcher accepts the offer or keeps its local repair plan. Both can use their usual phone line. Discuss • What must the dispatcher confirm before promising a crew? • Who can tell residents that pumping has actually resumed? One possible decision Keep the local plan in effect until the sending dispatcher confirms an arrival window. The water operator checks the pumps before the town announces that service is back. Follow up Ask both utilities to review a practice card showing when help was offered, accepted and on site. Use crew IDs without names. What to measure Replay the same delays, crews and backup power with current dispatch, a shared status card, then the card with AI flagging old entries. Count double assignments and hours pumping stops. Backup power may keep water flowing while repairs continue. Source Hydro One, “Hydro One awarded for outstanding restoration efforts after Hurricane Irma,” January 10, 2018. ──────────── Which water notice applies to this address? MAR goal Earn public trust through reviewable work. Neighbors can warn each other that a misleading notice is circulating. Each water provider keeps authority over its own advice, and renters can check which notice applies to them. Documented event After heavy rain and flooding upstream, Austin Water issued a boil-water notice on October 22, 2018. It lifted the notice on October 28. The City Council subsequently requested a public review of the response and its communications. Meeting exercise At 10 a.m., North Water lifts its notice. South Water confirms its notice remains in effect. A cropped picture saying “Notice lifted” reaches both towns. Decide what goes on each library door. Who does what Each utility supplies a dated notice and service-area map. Librarians check the issuing utility directly if the shared copy is unavailable. Discuss • How could a renter check the service area without showing a bill? • Whose confirmation would justify changing the sign in South’s service area? One possible decision North’s library posts North’s dated update. South’s library keeps South’s notice in place. Both display the issuer, area and confirmation time so residents can check or challenge the advice. Follow up Ask each library to test the signs with invented street addresses. Verify any disputed boundary with the provider before publishing. What to measure Give three teams the same notices and maps. Prepare signs the usual way, with a shared checklist, then with AI also flagging missing area names. Ask readers to match fictional addresses to notices. Count errors and extra checks. Source Austin City Council, Resolution No. 20181115-041, November 15, 2018. ──────────── Can riders find the replacement shuttle? MAR goal Make civilian service continuity the objective. A replacement bus keeps a trip possible only if the rider can reach it and board. Station and shuttle staff can check both parts before publishing directions. Documented event During Boston’s 2022 Orange Line shutdown, the city’s rider notice listed free shuttle buses, described the boarding lifts on many buses and told riders that wheelchair-accessible vans were available on request. Meeting exercise In a closure drill, the shuttle notice says to cross a footbridge and scan a code. The station confirms the step-free entrance is on Oak Street. The bus operator has yet to confirm whether the shuttle stops there. Who does what Station staff verify the walking route. The shuttle dispatcher confirms the boarding point and can offer a van. Riders can ask a station agent in person. Discuss • Which part of the trip is still unconfirmed? • What would help someone plan it with a paper notice? One possible decision Have the agent call dispatch before directing riders to Oak Street. Publish the verified boarding point and a staffed way to request assistance. Follow up Ask riders to trace the whole trip on paper. Record barriers they identify without collecting medical details. What to measure Give readers the usual directions, a notice checked by both operators, or one drafted with AI and checked by those same operators. Keep stops and vehicles fixed. Count workable transfer plans and details staff must correct. Source City of Boston, “Travel Options During Orange Line Shutdown,” August 2022. ──────────── Can families rely on a food pickup time? MAR goal Make civilian service continuity the objective. A food bank knows what it shipped. A school knows what families can collect. Sharing those two facts can prevent wasted trips and reveal a shortfall in time to request help. Documented event Houston Food Bank operated around the clock immediately after Hurricane Harvey. It reported that 42,530 food sacks went to children in schools in September 2017, showing how a distribution effort can reach families through a familiar place. Meeting exercise In a drill, 80 food boxes are due at noon. At noon the school counts 50. A neighboring pantry offers up to 20 more if the school asks. Decide what the school can promise now. Who does what The school confirms its count. The pantry decides how many boxes it can spare. If their shared list is down, the coordinators confirm by phone. Discuss • How many boxes are ready now? • If the pantry delivers all 20, how many of the 80 would still be missing? One possible decision Announce 50 boxes ready, accept the offer of 20 and give a time for the next update. Even after that delivery, 10 would still be missing. Follow up Ask a pantry and a school to try a paper tally of expected, received and promised boxes. Use counts without family names. What to measure Keep deliveries and families’ travel options fixed. Try usual practice, the shared tally, then the tally with AI checking for double counts. Let each household choose when to travel after its notice. Count boxes collected by closing time and trips that end empty-handed. Source Houston Food Bank, “Harvey Response,” August 2018. ──────────── Who received the message, and who understood it? MAR goal Require evidence before expansion. Hearing an alert and knowing what to do are two different outcomes. A small trial can reveal a message that needs work before an emergency office considers using it more widely. Documented event On October 4, 2023, FEMA and the FCC conducted a nationwide emergency alert test using mobile alerts and the broadcast alert system. The FCC reported that most respondents in the mobile-alert surveys it reviewed received the test message. Meeting exercise In a meeting-only drill, West Hall confirms a supply pickup has moved there from East Hall, with a further update at 3 p.m. An old paper sign still points to East Hall. Compare what residents would hear and read. Who does what The pickup coordinator confirms the change and next update time. Each venue checks its copy. Volunteers can describe anonymously what they heard or read. Discuss • Which notice might send someone to the wrong hall? • How could they confirm the change without a phone? One possible decision Station a greeter at East Hall and replace its sign. Use one checked message in both venues: “Practice pickup is at West Hall. The next update will be posted there at 3 p.m.” Follow up Take the corrected script and an anonymous tally of misunderstandings to the public information office. Record which formats still need testing. What to measure Compare the old messages, a checked script, and an AI-shortened version reviewed against it. Record how many volunteers in each group identify the right hall and update time. Townwide reach remains unknown. Source Federal Communications Commission, “October 4, 2023 Nationwide Emergency Alert Test,” June 2024. ──────────── Can displaced students attend class on Monday? MAR goal Protect civil liberties and private information. Two schools can arrange classroom space using seat counts. Each school can keep the names and circumstances of displaced families in its own care. Documented event On October 18, 2023, two elementary schools in Lāhainā reopened on one campus. The Maui fires had destroyed the King Kamehameha III Elementary campus, so its students shared the Princess Nāhiʻenaʻena Elementary site. Meeting exercise Lake School needs Monday places for 24 pupils. Hill School can offer 18 in the morning and six in the afternoon. Yesterday’s draft says “all pupils at 9.” Both principals can still change their plans. Who does what Hill’s principal confirms seats and times. Lake’s principal accepts the offer and contacts each family privately. A liaison checks who still needs help. Discuss • What must both principals confirm before families travel? • How could a family that cannot attend in the afternoon ask for another arrangement privately? One possible decision Confirm both sessions by phone. Lake sends session times through its own contact list, offers a callback and keeps a paper copy if the shared calendar fails. Follow up Ask a school liaison to rehearse the two calls using fictional counts. Have a parent read back the time and location. What to measure Compare an ordinary handoff with a confirmed seat count. Count pupils assigned a place they can use, mistaken arrivals and any names shared unnecessarily. A wrong assignment from an AI summary needs correction before a message goes out. Source Office of the Governor of Hawaiʻi, “Two State Agencies Collaborate to Help Lāhainā Students Return to Their Home Campuses,” November 1, 2023. ──────────── Can meal pickup continue on a smoky day? MAR goal Make civilian service continuity the objective. Smoke can cross a border while decisions about a local service stay local. The practical question is whether a verified warning and an offer of indoor space let families collect their meals. Documented event When smoke from Canadian wildfires reached New York City in June 2023, city health officials asked organizations to postpone outdoor activities, cancel them or move them indoors. The city also described uncertainty in the forecast. Meeting exercise A meal program serves 60 households outdoors. A host offers indoor pickup for 30 households at 11 and 30 at noon, subject to local guidance. An old message invites everyone at 11. Who does what The program checks the local advisory. The host confirms both slots. The program decides whether it can staff them and contacts households through its usual channels. Discuss • Which parts of the plan still need a person’s confirmation? • What happens to the second group if the noon offer is withdrawn? One possible decision Once both slots are confirmed and staffed, issue two pickup times and correct the old message. If noon falls through, staff call that group before travel and ask who needs another pickup option. Follow up Run the changed offer past a meal provider and a host. Ask who would own the correction in each organization. What to measure Replay the same warning and room offers. Count completed pickups, households turned away and staff time. Check whether an AI summary preserved both times before crediting it with saving work. Source NYC Mayor’s Office, public briefing on smoke from Canadian wildfires, June 7, 2023. ──────────── Which cleanup job still needs a crew? MAR goal Make costs and dependencies visible. Lending a crew takes it away from other local work. A report from the delivery driver helps dispatch check whether a second trip would reopen another entrance or use scarce crew time twice on the same job. Documented event After the 2023 ice storm, Austin closed existing 3-1-1 storm-debris requests at the end of March. In April, crews began another citywide collection pass. A closed request alone could not tell a resident whether the crew had visited their street. Meeting exercise Three tickets say “closed.” A meal-delivery driver reports branches blocking a loading entrance. The city has one crew. A neighboring district can lend one for the morning if the city confirms a second job. Who does what Dispatch checks the driver’s report against the crew log. The neighbor decides what it can spare. The site manager can confirm when deliveries resume. Discuss • Which location can the driver actually verify? • Would a second crew help if only one blocked entrance has been confirmed? One possible decision Send one crew to the verified job. Keep the other locations unconfirmed, invite corrections and release the neighbor’s crew unless a separate need is verified. Record when the entrance can receive deliveries. Follow up Ask a public-works supervisor and a service operator to review the three records and name who can correct one. What to measure Compare dispatch from ticket status alone with a check against local reports. Count crew-hours borrowed, duplicate trips and time until the next delivery can enter. Include unfinished work in the lending district. Source Austin Resource Recovery, Director’s Monthly Report to the Zero Waste Advisory Commission, April 12, 2023. ──────────── Has the receiving post confirmed the mail arrived? MAR goal Use practical diplomacy to reduce misunderstanding. A narrow question about civilian mail gives two postal operators a reason to stay in contact during disruption. Each can verify its own end of a handoff without disclosing the contents of anyone’s letters. Documented event On March 4, 2022, the Universal Postal Union reported that postal operators in Latvia, Poland and Slovakia were working with Ukraine’s postal service to keep international mail moving during the war. Meeting exercise Use two fictional postal operators. One confirms sending a batch of mail. The receiving office has no arrival record yet. A translated draft tells customers their letters are ready for pickup. Who does what The sending post confirms dispatch. The receiving post checks its local register and decides when pickup can begin. Either can request clarification by phone. Discuss • What can each operator say firsthand? • What could staff publish if the partner cannot be reached? One possible decision Tell customers the batch has been sent and receipt is still unconfirmed. Give a time for the next update. The receiving office issues the pickup notice after checking its own record. Follow up Ask a postal liaison to review a sample handoff slip using a fictional batch number, status and time. What to measure Using identical updates, compare current practice, a shared status slip and the slip with AI translation. Count premature pickup notices, avoidable trips and time spent resolving discrepancies. Source Universal Postal Union, Director General’s statement on the conflict in Ukraine, March 4, 2022. ──────────── Can two shelters make room for evacuating families’ pets? MAR goal Keep people accountable for consequential decisions. Checking a partner’s offer of space can keep temporary boarding available to families. The shelter responsible for an animal retains the decision about whether it can be moved. Documented event During the Palisades and Eaton fires in January 2025, Los Angeles County worked with rescue partners to move unowned animals and make space for displaced pets. Its report identified the animals transferred to rescue groups as unowned. Meeting exercise A full shelter has six animals. Staff have cleared two for transfer, three are boarded for families and one status is unknown. A rescue offers two places. Two evacuated households are waiting, each with one pet. Who does what The rescue confirms capacity. Shelter staff check eligibility, authorize transfers and confirm a space is actually free before offering it to a family. Discuss • What can staff promise before the transfer is complete? • If one rescue space is withdrawn, how many families can the shelter welcome? One possible decision With both places confirmed, transfer only the two cleared animals and verify their arrival. Offer boarding as places open. If only one place opens, help the second family find another confirmed option. Follow up Rehearse with fictional animal identifiers and capacity counts. Keep family contact details with the shelter and off the shared list. What to measure Compare the usual referral call with a checked capacity list. Count households actually offered boarding, incorrect transfers and staff minutes. Reject a quicker AI match if it treats an unknown status as approval. Source Los Angeles County Department of Animal Care and Control, report on adoption and rescue efforts during the Palisades and Eaton fires, January 16, 2025. ──────────── Meeting worksheet Which service matters here, and to whom? ______________________________________________________ Who offers help, who checks it and who decides? ______________________________________________________ Which claim did we check, and where? ______________________________________________________ If help falls through, what can each partner still do? ______________________________________________________ What outcome or cost would change the decision? ______________________________________________________ Who will take the next step, and by when? ______________________________________________________ ──────────── Public recap to adapt On [date], we considered how [partners] could keep [service] available during [disruption]. In our exercise, [who] checked [information] before [who] decided whether to act. The historical source documents [fact and source date]. Our group observed [result or unresolved question]. We would [continue, change or stop the exercise] if [evidence or cost]. One concern or differing view was [point raised]. [Person or office that agreed] will [next step] by [date]. We’ll share the answer or a progress note at [public location or link]. Send corrections to [contact]. ──────────── For candidates and public offices Find the candidate guide and its one-page printable brief under “For candidates and public offices” on the Safe Nations website.