Safe Nations | Independent review worksheet Write privately. Keep only details needed to check the claim. Set the scope Scenario and status as fictional or real ____________________________________________________________ Relevant MAR policy commitment ____________________________________________________________ Original source, date, and location ____________________________________________________________ Date of review ____________________________________________________________ Reviewer or role, review type, method, scope, and conflicts of interest ____________________________________________________________ Limits of this review ____________________________________________________________ Claim being evaluated ____________________________________________________________ Record the evidence What was observed directly? ____________________________________________________________ What was reported but still needs confirmation? ____________________________________________________________ What remains unknown? ____________________________________________________________ Initial independent decision and why ____________________________________________________________ Best competing explanation or simpler non-AI option ____________________________________________________________ AI output, if any. Label a mock result as simulated. ____________________________________________________________ Record the comparison Who can authorize, decline, correct, or suspend the arrangement? ____________________________________________________________ Civilian outcome and unacceptable harm set in advance ____________________________________________________________ Results of the comparison, if run ____________________________________________________________ Privacy, accessibility, and disconnection or withdrawal safeguards ____________________________________________________________ Explain the reviewed decision Reviewed decision [ ] Approve a limited further test [ ] Revise and retest [ ] Defer pending evidence [ ] Reject this proposal Preferred approach [ ] Keep the usual process [ ] Use the simpler non-AI process [ ] Test the added AI step in a limited exercise [ ] Do not adopt or cancel proposed cooperation Evidence status [ ] Proposal [ ] Rehearsal observation [ ] Independently verified result [ ] Unresolved Reason for the reviewed decision ____________________________________________________________ What changed your mind, if anything? ____________________________________________________________ Minority view or dissent (optional) ____________________________________________________________ What evidence would overturn the conclusion or trigger a pause? ____________________________________________________________ Next evidence, correction, or authorized review ____________________________________________________________ Jesse Shelley · CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 · https://safenations.org/